Sydenews
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Crime
    • Judiciary
    • Religion
    WHO Urges Nigeria, Others To Hike Taxes On Sugary Drinks, Alcohol, Tobacco by 50%

    WHO Urges Nigeria, Others To Hike Taxes On Sugary Drinks, Alcohol, Tobacco by 50%

    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Lagos Police Bust Crime Rings, Recover 36 Exotic Cars, Arrest 50 Cultists

    Maida Confirmed As Executive Vice Chairman Of NCC

    NCC Unveils First-Ever Regulatory Impact Assessment To Reform Telecom Laws

    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Driver Sentenced For Illegal Trafficking Of Parrots

    FG, KACCIMA, Extol Dangote Over Sponsorship Of Kano Fair

    Dangote’s Initiative  Will Cut Costs, Tame Inflation, Boost Economy – Energy Experts

    Smile Nigeria: Connecting Nigerians To What Truly Matters

    Smile Nigeria: Connecting Nigerians To What Truly Matters

    Ill-timed panic and the real truth behind police pension reforms- By Ambrose Ijeuwa

    Ill-timed panic and the real truth behind police pension reforms- By Ambrose Ijeuwa

    FG, KACCIMA, Extol Dangote Over Sponsorship Of Kano Fair

    Dangote Remains A Pillar Of Nigeria’s Financial Market – NGX Group Chairman

    Wema Bank Staff, Others Remanded Over Alleged N8.5 Billion Fraud

    Wema Bank Staff, Others Remanded Over Alleged N8.5 Billion Fraud

  • Politics

    Gov. Yusuf Commends Food Vendors In Kano Over Ramadan Feeding

    Kano Govt Issues Executive Order On Kwankwasiyya, Amana, Bandirawo Cities

    Kano Govt Issues Executive Order On Kwankwasiyya, Amana, Bandirawo Cities

    Methodological  Of CPI Won’t Bring Down Inflation, Adebayo Tells FG

    SDP Will Remove Tinubu In 2027 – Adebayo

    Gov. Yusuf Donates N3b Land For North West Development Commission Headquarters In Kano

    Gov. Yusuf Donates N3b Land For North West Development Commission Headquarters In Kano

    Gov. Yusuf Named African Governor Of The Year For Good Governance

    Canada’s RISE Project  Set To Boost Agriculture, Empower Women, Youth In Kano

    Gov. Yusuf Engages Increased World Bank On More Support For Kano

    Gov. Yusuf Engages Increased World Bank On More Support For Kano

    Political Turmoil in Major Parties as SDP Gains Ground Ahead of 2027

    Prince Adebayo Welcome To El-Rufai Into SDP

    Urban Renewal: Gov. Yusuf Flags Off Rehabilitation Of 17 Roads  In Kano Metropolis

    Urban Renewal: Gov. Yusuf Flags Off Rehabilitation Of 17 Roads  In Kano Metropolis

    Gov. Yusuf Named African Governor Of The Year For Good Governance

    Gov Yusuf Orders Probe Into Salary Deductions Of Kano Civil Servants

  • Lifestyle
    Ban Junk, Protect Nigerians — CAPPA Tells FG, States

    Ban Junk, Protect Nigerians — CAPPA Tells FG, States

    Family Marks one-year Memorial Of Late APC Chieftain, Ojougboh With Charity Outreach

    Family Marks one-year Memorial Of Late APC Chieftain, Ojougboh With Charity Outreach

    Kamdi Okeke Leads USA Team Wins Award, Rolls Out Coding Camp In Sub-Sahara Africa 

    Kamdi Okeke Leads USA Team Wins Award, Rolls Out Coding Camp In Sub-Sahara Africa 

    Wale Edun, Ribadu, Dele Alake, Others Appointed As Tinubu Special Advisers

    APC NEC Meeting: Inconsequential, Greedy Elements Determined to Endorse Ganduje

    Nestlé MD, Employees Mentor 12,000 Students

    Nestle Faces Criticism Over High Sugar Levels In Baby Products

    Why We Arrested Bobrisky- EFCC

    Why We Arrested Bobrisky- EFCC

    Restoration For Worshippers, As SCOAN Ends 3-Days Marathon Revival

    Restoration For Worshippers, As SCOAN Ends 3-Days Marathon Revival

    NFVCB, Tobacco Community Commit To Smoke-free Nollywood

    NFVCB, Tobacco Community Commit To Smoke-free Nollywood

    Cean Joseph releases new single – Running After

    Cean Joseph releases new single – Running After

  • Judiciary
    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Driver Sentenced For Illegal Trafficking Of Parrots

    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Woman Drags Fashion Designer To Court Over Alleged Blackmail

    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Teacher Bags Life Imprisonment For Defiling Pupil

    ECOWAS Court Kicks-off External Session In Lagos To Strengthens Push For Justice

    ECOWAS Court Kicks-off External Session In Lagos To Strengthens Push For Justice

    How DSS Officials Used Fake Names, Unmarked Vehicles To Invade Our Office’, SERAP Tells Court

    SERAP, NGE Demand Tinubu End Cybercrime Act Abuse, Free Detained Journalists

    Chidinma: Police Forced Me To Lie In Statement On Ataga’s Death

    Chidinma: Police Forced Me To Lie In Statement On Ataga’s Death

    Court Nullifies Obasa’s Removal As Lagos Speaker

    Court Nullifies Obasa’s Removal As Lagos Speaker

    Alleged Fraud: Peter Okoye of P-Square Testifies Against Brother, Jude, In ₦1.38bn Case

    Alleged Fraud: Peter Okoye of P-Square Testifies Against Brother, Jude, In ₦1.38bn Case

    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Barber Gets Life Imprisonment For Defiling Girl, 15

  • Crime
    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Lagos Police Bust Crime Rings, Recover 36 Exotic Cars, Arrest 50 Cultists

    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Police Capture Mushin’s Most Wanted Gang Leader ‘Olori Eso’

    June 12: What Lagos Police and Civil Society Groups Just Agreed On

    June 12: What Lagos Police and Civil Society Groups Just Agreed On

    Deserting Operatives Of Nigeria’s JTF Against Boko Haram To Face Sanctions 

    Deserting Operatives Of Nigeria’s JTF Against Boko Haram To Face Sanctions 

    Land Dispute Rocks Delta Community as Ubulu-Uku Citizens Cry Betrayal

    Land Dispute Rocks Delta Community as Ubulu-Uku Citizens Cry Betrayal

    IGP Orders Probe Into Killing Of 14-Year-Old In Oyo 

    IGP Orders Probe Into Killing Of 14-Year-Old In Oyo 

    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Police Arrest Father Who Beat Libya Returnee Daughter To Death 

    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Police Bust ‘Yahoo School’ In Lagos, Arrest 10 Suspects

    FCT Police Commissioner Vows To Prioritize Intelligence-Driven Policing

    FCT Police Commissioner Vows To Prioritize Intelligence-Driven Policing

  • Religion
    Viral ‘Gun’ Drama: Pastor Adefarasin Turns Self In

    Viral ‘Gun’ Drama: Pastor Adefarasin Turns Self In

    African Need More Leaders Like Ibrahim Traore, Says Dr Chris Okafor

    African Need More Leaders Like Ibrahim Traore, Says Dr Chris Okafor

    Primate Ayodele VS Osun APC: Oyetola, They Are Leading You To The Pit Again –  By Adeosun Olashile

    Is Governor Sanwoolu Scared Of Primate Ayodele’s Prophecy? (VIDEO)

    CEAN UNVEILS “LIFTED” FEATURING PSALMOS

    CEAN UNVEILS “LIFTED” FEATURING PSALMOS

    Eulogizing the magnanimous impact of Primate Elijah Ayodele (Part 2)

    Primate Ayodele’s Prophecy Comes To Pass As Burkina Faso Junta Leader Survives Coup Plot (VIDEO)

    Asagba Of Asaba Calls For Election Of African Cardinal As Next Pope

    Asagba Of Asaba Calls For Election Of African Cardinal As Next Pope

    Evangelist Ebuka Obi Denies Involvement In ‘Ijele Speaks’ Detention

    Evangelist Ebuka Obi Denies Involvement In ‘Ijele Speaks’ Detention

    Between Primate Ayodele and Sacked NNPC Boss, Mele Kyari, Who Laughs Last? –  Shina Dayo

    Between Primate Ayodele and Sacked NNPC Boss, Mele Kyari, Who Laughs Last? –  Shina Dayo

    Police, Religious Leaders Urge Journalists to Promote Unity During Ramadan, Lent

    Police, Religious Leaders Urge Journalists to Promote Unity During Ramadan, Lent

  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Crime
    • Judiciary
    • Religion
    WHO Urges Nigeria, Others To Hike Taxes On Sugary Drinks, Alcohol, Tobacco by 50%

    WHO Urges Nigeria, Others To Hike Taxes On Sugary Drinks, Alcohol, Tobacco by 50%

    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Lagos Police Bust Crime Rings, Recover 36 Exotic Cars, Arrest 50 Cultists

    Maida Confirmed As Executive Vice Chairman Of NCC

    NCC Unveils First-Ever Regulatory Impact Assessment To Reform Telecom Laws

    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Driver Sentenced For Illegal Trafficking Of Parrots

    FG, KACCIMA, Extol Dangote Over Sponsorship Of Kano Fair

    Dangote’s Initiative  Will Cut Costs, Tame Inflation, Boost Economy – Energy Experts

    Smile Nigeria: Connecting Nigerians To What Truly Matters

    Smile Nigeria: Connecting Nigerians To What Truly Matters

    Ill-timed panic and the real truth behind police pension reforms- By Ambrose Ijeuwa

    Ill-timed panic and the real truth behind police pension reforms- By Ambrose Ijeuwa

    FG, KACCIMA, Extol Dangote Over Sponsorship Of Kano Fair

    Dangote Remains A Pillar Of Nigeria’s Financial Market – NGX Group Chairman

    Wema Bank Staff, Others Remanded Over Alleged N8.5 Billion Fraud

    Wema Bank Staff, Others Remanded Over Alleged N8.5 Billion Fraud

  • Politics

    Gov. Yusuf Commends Food Vendors In Kano Over Ramadan Feeding

    Kano Govt Issues Executive Order On Kwankwasiyya, Amana, Bandirawo Cities

    Kano Govt Issues Executive Order On Kwankwasiyya, Amana, Bandirawo Cities

    Methodological  Of CPI Won’t Bring Down Inflation, Adebayo Tells FG

    SDP Will Remove Tinubu In 2027 – Adebayo

    Gov. Yusuf Donates N3b Land For North West Development Commission Headquarters In Kano

    Gov. Yusuf Donates N3b Land For North West Development Commission Headquarters In Kano

    Gov. Yusuf Named African Governor Of The Year For Good Governance

    Canada’s RISE Project  Set To Boost Agriculture, Empower Women, Youth In Kano

    Gov. Yusuf Engages Increased World Bank On More Support For Kano

    Gov. Yusuf Engages Increased World Bank On More Support For Kano

    Political Turmoil in Major Parties as SDP Gains Ground Ahead of 2027

    Prince Adebayo Welcome To El-Rufai Into SDP

    Urban Renewal: Gov. Yusuf Flags Off Rehabilitation Of 17 Roads  In Kano Metropolis

    Urban Renewal: Gov. Yusuf Flags Off Rehabilitation Of 17 Roads  In Kano Metropolis

    Gov. Yusuf Named African Governor Of The Year For Good Governance

    Gov Yusuf Orders Probe Into Salary Deductions Of Kano Civil Servants

  • Lifestyle
    Ban Junk, Protect Nigerians — CAPPA Tells FG, States

    Ban Junk, Protect Nigerians — CAPPA Tells FG, States

    Family Marks one-year Memorial Of Late APC Chieftain, Ojougboh With Charity Outreach

    Family Marks one-year Memorial Of Late APC Chieftain, Ojougboh With Charity Outreach

    Kamdi Okeke Leads USA Team Wins Award, Rolls Out Coding Camp In Sub-Sahara Africa 

    Kamdi Okeke Leads USA Team Wins Award, Rolls Out Coding Camp In Sub-Sahara Africa 

    Wale Edun, Ribadu, Dele Alake, Others Appointed As Tinubu Special Advisers

    APC NEC Meeting: Inconsequential, Greedy Elements Determined to Endorse Ganduje

    Nestlé MD, Employees Mentor 12,000 Students

    Nestle Faces Criticism Over High Sugar Levels In Baby Products

    Why We Arrested Bobrisky- EFCC

    Why We Arrested Bobrisky- EFCC

    Restoration For Worshippers, As SCOAN Ends 3-Days Marathon Revival

    Restoration For Worshippers, As SCOAN Ends 3-Days Marathon Revival

    NFVCB, Tobacco Community Commit To Smoke-free Nollywood

    NFVCB, Tobacco Community Commit To Smoke-free Nollywood

    Cean Joseph releases new single – Running After

    Cean Joseph releases new single – Running After

  • Judiciary
    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Driver Sentenced For Illegal Trafficking Of Parrots

    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Woman Drags Fashion Designer To Court Over Alleged Blackmail

    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Teacher Bags Life Imprisonment For Defiling Pupil

    ECOWAS Court Kicks-off External Session In Lagos To Strengthens Push For Justice

    ECOWAS Court Kicks-off External Session In Lagos To Strengthens Push For Justice

    How DSS Officials Used Fake Names, Unmarked Vehicles To Invade Our Office’, SERAP Tells Court

    SERAP, NGE Demand Tinubu End Cybercrime Act Abuse, Free Detained Journalists

    Chidinma: Police Forced Me To Lie In Statement On Ataga’s Death

    Chidinma: Police Forced Me To Lie In Statement On Ataga’s Death

    Court Nullifies Obasa’s Removal As Lagos Speaker

    Court Nullifies Obasa’s Removal As Lagos Speaker

    Alleged Fraud: Peter Okoye of P-Square Testifies Against Brother, Jude, In ₦1.38bn Case

    Alleged Fraud: Peter Okoye of P-Square Testifies Against Brother, Jude, In ₦1.38bn Case

    Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial

    Barber Gets Life Imprisonment For Defiling Girl, 15

  • Crime
    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Lagos Police Bust Crime Rings, Recover 36 Exotic Cars, Arrest 50 Cultists

    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Police Capture Mushin’s Most Wanted Gang Leader ‘Olori Eso’

    June 12: What Lagos Police and Civil Society Groups Just Agreed On

    June 12: What Lagos Police and Civil Society Groups Just Agreed On

    Deserting Operatives Of Nigeria’s JTF Against Boko Haram To Face Sanctions 

    Deserting Operatives Of Nigeria’s JTF Against Boko Haram To Face Sanctions 

    Land Dispute Rocks Delta Community as Ubulu-Uku Citizens Cry Betrayal

    Land Dispute Rocks Delta Community as Ubulu-Uku Citizens Cry Betrayal

    IGP Orders Probe Into Killing Of 14-Year-Old In Oyo 

    IGP Orders Probe Into Killing Of 14-Year-Old In Oyo 

    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Police Arrest Father Who Beat Libya Returnee Daughter To Death 

    Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda

    Police Bust ‘Yahoo School’ In Lagos, Arrest 10 Suspects

    FCT Police Commissioner Vows To Prioritize Intelligence-Driven Policing

    FCT Police Commissioner Vows To Prioritize Intelligence-Driven Policing

  • Religion
    Viral ‘Gun’ Drama: Pastor Adefarasin Turns Self In

    Viral ‘Gun’ Drama: Pastor Adefarasin Turns Self In

    African Need More Leaders Like Ibrahim Traore, Says Dr Chris Okafor

    African Need More Leaders Like Ibrahim Traore, Says Dr Chris Okafor

    Primate Ayodele VS Osun APC: Oyetola, They Are Leading You To The Pit Again –  By Adeosun Olashile

    Is Governor Sanwoolu Scared Of Primate Ayodele’s Prophecy? (VIDEO)

    CEAN UNVEILS “LIFTED” FEATURING PSALMOS

    CEAN UNVEILS “LIFTED” FEATURING PSALMOS

    Eulogizing the magnanimous impact of Primate Elijah Ayodele (Part 2)

    Primate Ayodele’s Prophecy Comes To Pass As Burkina Faso Junta Leader Survives Coup Plot (VIDEO)

    Asagba Of Asaba Calls For Election Of African Cardinal As Next Pope

    Asagba Of Asaba Calls For Election Of African Cardinal As Next Pope

    Evangelist Ebuka Obi Denies Involvement In ‘Ijele Speaks’ Detention

    Evangelist Ebuka Obi Denies Involvement In ‘Ijele Speaks’ Detention

    Between Primate Ayodele and Sacked NNPC Boss, Mele Kyari, Who Laughs Last? –  Shina Dayo

    Between Primate Ayodele and Sacked NNPC Boss, Mele Kyari, Who Laughs Last? –  Shina Dayo

    Police, Religious Leaders Urge Journalists to Promote Unity During Ramadan, Lent

    Police, Religious Leaders Urge Journalists to Promote Unity During Ramadan, Lent

  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Sydenews
No Result
View All Result
Home News Judiciary

Appeal Court Rejects Bi-Courtney’s Challenge To N500m Judgment Sum

in Judiciary, News
0
Couple Arraigned For Allegedly Defrauded Standard Chartered Bank
491
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Court of Appeal in Lagos has dismissed Bi-Courtney Limited’s appeal against a Lagos High Court ruling concerning a N500 million loan from Aso Savings Limited and Abacus Estate Limited.

The appellate court, led by Justice Obande Festus Ogbuinya, found the appeal lacked merit and upheld the lower court’s decision by Justice Adeniyi Onigbanjo.

In 2009, Aso Savings Limited provided the loan to Bi-Courtney, with a property as collateral. However, Bi-Courtney defaulted on repayment, leading to legal actions. An amicable settlement was reached but not adhered to, resulting in Aso Savings selling the property to Abacus Estate Limited.

The Appellate Court in its judgement delivered by Justice Obande Festus Ogbuinya held that the appeal is bereft of any iota of merit, and dismissed it accordingly.

The court in it’s unanimous decision also affirm the decision of the lower court delivered by Justice Adeniyi Onigbanjo (now retired), on July 11, 2017.

According to court documents, sometime in 2009, Aso Savings Limited granted a credit facility of N500 million to Bi-Courtney Limited, on some terms and conditions.

The Appellant, Bi-Courtney Limited had mortgaged its property, situate and known as 70 Alexander Avenue, Ikoyi, Eti-Osa Local Government Area, Lagos State (the property) as collateral for the loan.

The appellant, Bi-Courtney Limited however defaulted in repayment of the facility. 

In 2010, the respondent, Aso Savings Limited, filed an action against the Bi-Courtney Limited, in the lower court, registered as Suit No. LD/925/2010, for the foreclosure of the legal mortgage.

In response, the Appellant raised a preliminary objection to the suit. before the ruling on the objection was delivered, both parties have reached an amicable settlement ‘which was reduced into Terms of Settlement, which was entered on June 20, 2011, as Consent Judgment before Justice M. O. Obadina, which has generated tons of litigations. 

However, the Appellant, Bi-Courtney Limited, defaulted in obeying the consent judgment. As a result, Aso Savings Limited, in compliance with the consent judgment, sold the property to Abacus Estate Limited (second respondent) and put it in possession thereon. 

Sequel to that, the appellant had besieged the lower court, via an originating summons filed on 20th October, 2016, praying for a declaration that pursuant to Order 5 Rule 1(1) of the High Court of  Lagos State (Civil Procedure) Rules 2004 (which was in force as at the time Suit No. M/925/2010 was instituted), Suit No. M/925/2010 is a nullity. 

It also prayed the court for an order setting aside and or nullifying the proceedings as well as the Consent Judgment.

However, Aso Savings Limited filed a preliminary objection, and urged the court to dismiss the suit for lack of jurisdiction among other reliefs.

Justice Onigbanjo in his Ruling delivered on July 11, 2017 upheld the preliminary objection and dismissed Bi-Courtney Limited’s suit, for amounting to an abuse of court process.

Dissatisfied with Justice Onigbanjo’s ruling, Bi-Courtney Limited, approached Appeal Court in it Notice of Appeal asked for setting aside the ruling of the lower court.

However, the 3-man panel, comprising of Justice Obande Ogbuinya (Presided), Justice Abubakar Umar and Justice Abdullahi Bayero dismissed the appeal.

In his lead judgement delivered on June 27, 2023, Justice Ogbuinya held that the lower court did not trampled on the Appellant’s sacrosanct right to fair hearing as to fetch the reprobation of the court.

The Court held “The appellant was properly heard. The lower court did not trample on the appellant’s sacrosanct right to fair hearing as to fetch the reprobation of this court. 

“My noble Lords, for the avoidance of any ambiguity, it is important to assemble and synthesise the divergent resolutions and apportion their concomitant consequences on the appeal. I had resolved issue one in favour of the appellant and issues two and three against it and vice versa.

“Alas, the appellant only gained pyrrhic victory on the resolution of the issue one in its favour. The reason is this. The outcome of issues two and three, which went against it, overshadows and drowns the resolution of issue one and, ipso facto (by the fact itself) will define and shape the ultimate destiny and verdict in the appeal. 

“On the whole, having resolved issues two and three against the appellant, the fortune of the appeal is obvious. It is bereft of any iota of merit and deserves the reserved penalty of dismissal. 

“Consequently, I dismiss the appeal. I affirm the decision (ruling) of the lower court which was delivered on 11th July, 2017”

Other members of the panel concurred with Justice Ogbuinya’s decision.

Tags: Aso Savings LimitedBi-Courtney LimitedCourt of Appeal LagosJustice Obande Festus OgbuinyaSydenewwBBC

Related Posts

WHO Urges Nigeria, Others To Hike Taxes On Sugary Drinks, Alcohol, Tobacco by 50%
News

WHO Urges Nigeria, Others To Hike Taxes On Sugary Drinks, Alcohol, Tobacco by 50%

Police Restore Lagos Speaker’s Security, Meranda
Crime

Lagos Police Bust Crime Rings, Recover 36 Exotic Cars, Arrest 50 Cultists

Maida Confirmed As Executive Vice Chairman Of NCC
Business

NCC Unveils First-Ever Regulatory Impact Assessment To Reform Telecom Laws

Chartered Accountant Appeals High Court’s Decision Over Bail Denial
Judiciary

Driver Sentenced For Illegal Trafficking Of Parrots

Facebook Twitter Youtube RSS
sydenews logo

Get the Latest Top Stories, Breaking news in Nigeria with in-depth coverage on crime, judiciary and politics

Follow us on social media:

Recent News

  • WHO Urges Nigeria, Others To Hike Taxes On Sugary Drinks, Alcohol, Tobacco by 50%
  • Lagos Police Bust Crime Rings, Recover 36 Exotic Cars, Arrest 50 Cultists
  • NCC Unveils First-Ever Regulatory Impact Assessment To Reform Telecom Laws

Category

  • Business
  • Crime
  • Culture
  • Judiciary
  • Lifestyle
  • National
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Religion
  • Sports
  • Uncategorized
  • World
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • News
  • Lifestyle
  • Crime
  • Religion

© 2024 Sydenews - Get the Latest Top Stories, Breaking news in Nigeria.